Hello fine people.. And so it goes… today I figured I’d venture away from my regular rants about life here and Jordan.. and inform you about a conversation I had earlier in the week. As most of you know I am attending classes with students that are on average 12-15 years younger than me. And as in most cases with youth.. they think they know everything about how the world works, and what it takes to fix it.. And so begins the conversation about raising children like dogs.
Yes you read that correctly. I had an conversation with a childless person, who said the reason the world is messed up is because people don’t raise their children like dogs, to obey them. This childless person.. wait let me stop.. I know many people with out children who would think this argument is dumb.. Let’s say.. hmm.. this person who has not spent much time around children.. yes, that sounds better…
This person said that if you raise children like dogs, from the beginning.. and teach them how to obey you, they will grow up to be better adults. His shining example was a couple who was doing that, and who’s young child obeyed everything they said… If they said sit, the kid sat, if they said stand the kid stood…. Interesting enough.. it turns out the kid has a speech delay.. or doesn’t talk.. (I didn’t go into details).. but my response to this is that these people are raising a future serial killer.
Having no kids of my own, but having played a role in raising my nieces and nephews.. and having worked in education for over 15 years.. I found this idea completely ludicrous (insert Mike Tyson lisp).. I mean for real… raising your child like a pet?
So yeah. You can imagine the look on my face… this mis-guided youth thinks that you can program a child…. Their example is that they would train their child to like chocolate cake.. somehow they think that, as with a dog, if you reinforce certain behaviors you can train a child to like/dislike anything. And that buy using pet raising methods, you can garantee that all of yoru children will turn out the same and be a success. Which may be the case.. but I would argue as to weather this child is “healthy” on a psychological level.
My response is that each individual human being is born with preset likes/dislikes and though some things can be trained, ultimately a child/human will at some point ignore everything they have been taught and choose to like what ever they want.. to stand up when they feel like it, or eat vanilla cake if they so choose…
I could ramble on.. but I would like to hear comments form the peanut gallery… Can you raise a child like a dog, to respond on command.. and if so, will the child be mentally healthy or a future serial killer/social misfit?

You should have said " I'm not talking to you until you go see planet of the apes, you will learn that not even an ape can be raise as a pet" :-)
ReplyDelete